top of page

Supreme Court Limits Cumulus Delay In Nielsen Ratings Fight.

4 hours ago
3 min read

The Supreme Court has given Cumulus Media eight more days to respond to Nielsen’s appeal in their radio ratings antitrust battle, rejecting the broadcaster’s request for a month-long extension. The decision keeps alive the possibility that the justices could hear arguments in the case during their current term, a timetable Nielsen had warned was at risk if Cumulus received the additional time it wanted.


The court's order sets a new Dec. 15 deadline for Cumulus to file its response to Nielsen’s petition seeking Supreme Court review of a ruling blocking its national and local radio ratings sales policy. That falls well short of the Jan. 6 deadline Cumulus requested earlier this week. It is also just one day later than the Dec. 14 deadline Nielsen had volunteered it would accept.


The timing matters because Nielsen warned the justices that a longer delay could effectively prevent the Supreme Court from hearing arguments in the case during its current term.


Nielsen had offered to promptly file its reply, or waive the remainder of its allotted response period, if Cumulus submitted its opposition by Dec. 14. That would potentially allow the justices to consider Nielsen’s petition at their Jan. 8, 2027 conference.


Timing aside, a bigger issue remains undecided. The Supreme Court hasn’t yet indicated when it will consider the petition. But the shorter extension leaves open the possibility of review on a timetable close to the one Nielsen proposed.


Nielsen Fights Delay


The ruling follows competing filings from the companies over how much additional time Cumulus should receive.


Cumulus requested a 30-day extension, citing several competing legal deadlines, including a Nov. 24 oral argument before the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in a related Nielsen case. The broadcaster also pointed to other pending litigation, scheduled depositions and the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays.


Nielsen opposed the monthlong extension, arguing that Cumulus had already enjoyed ample time to prepare its response. The ratings company noted that it filed its Supreme Court petition Sept. 15 and that Cumulus initially waived its right to respond. The Supreme Court subsequently requested a response.


Nielsen also warned that delaying Supreme Court review could leave the company subject to continued judicial oversight of its pricing under the preliminary injunction it is challenging. It argued that the appeals court ruling could also be invoked in other antitrust cases while its challenge remains unresolved.


Supreme Court Review Uncertain


The underlying dispute dates to October 2025, when Cumulus sued Nielsen over a policy requiring broadcasters to purchase local radio ratings to obtain complete Nationwide ratings.


Cumulus wanted to continue purchasing Nielsen’s national ratings for its Westwood One network business while using rival Eastlan for local audience measurement in certain markets.


District Judge Jeannette Vargas issued a preliminary injunction in December 2025 prohibiting Nielsen from conditioning access to its complete national ratings on local ratings purchases. The order also barred Nielsen from charging commercially unreasonable prices for Nationwide ratings sold separately.


The Second Circuit upheld the injunction in July, rejecting Nielsen’s challenge to the ruling.


Nielsen has asked the Supreme Court to intervene, arguing that the appeals court improperly treated its discounted package of national and local ratings as an unlawful tying arrangement without sufficient evidence that the pricing excluded competitors. The company contends the ruling could have consequences beyond radio by exposing common bundled discounts to antitrust challenges in other industries.


The Supreme Court’s decision to request a response from Cumulus earlier this month was a potentially encouraging development for Nielsen, since the justices could have rejected its petition without seeking the broadcaster’s arguments. But the court hasn’t agreed to hear the case, and its latest order addresses only the deadline for Cumulus to respond.


Meanwhile, a separate Second Circuit appeal continues over enforcement of the original injunction. Judge Vargas previously rejected Nielsen’s proposed standalone Nationwide pricing as commercially unreasonable and threatened daily penalties of $50,000 unless the company submitted a revised offer. The appeals court stayed that enforcement order while Nielsen’s challenge proceeds.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page