top of page

Radio’s Q3 Results Reflects A Changing Ad Market.

43 minutes ago
3 min read

Broadcasters reporting sluggish third quarter advertising revenue may have more company than they realize. New analysis from Guideline suggests the advertising slowdown extends well beyond radio, with underlying U.S. ad spending barely growing during the quarter once major technology platforms and blockbuster sporting events are removed from the equation.


Guideline Chief Insights and Analytics Officer Sean Wright says the broader weakness may help explain why several major media companies have reported advertising results that fell short of expectations. And he thinks the industry may be overlooking a common denominator.


"I would argue that there is something else at play that is not yet being talked about, but what is showing up in the data — and that is the slowing ad market," Wright says on the company's "Media Monitor" podcast.


Guideline data shows U.S. agency ad spending increased 5.5% during the third quarter. That was a respectable gain, but the headline figure masks a considerably weaker underlying market. When spending with Google, Meta and Amazon is excluded, the growth rate drops to 3%. Strip away the incremental advertising associated with major sporting events, including the World Cup, and growth falls to just 1%.


Wright estimates the overall U.S. advertising market, including spending outside Guideline's agency dataset, may have expanded closer to 8% during the quarter. But even on that broader basis, he believes underlying growth excluding the largest technology companies and major sporting events was probably only 2% to 3%.


Traditional media isn't alone in feeling the pressure. Wright points to advertising results and commentary from companies including Netflix, Google, Amazon and Meta as evidence that even the industry's largest digital players aren't immune to the broader slowdown.


“Part of why we are seeing companies ever so slightly miss their Q3 earnings is because we are seeing fundamentally a slowdown in the market tied to broader economic headwinds," Wright says.


While broadcasters have been dealing with pressure on traditional media budgets, Guideline's findings suggest some of the Q3 softness may also reflect broader economic conditions affecting media companies across the board. Guideline doesn't provide radio-specific spending figures. But the findings provide additional context for broadcasters evaluating their own results against the wider advertising marketplace.


World Cup Shifted Budgets


The slowdown also became more pronounced as the third quarter progressed. Guideline's data shows a roughly 2% to 3% shift in overall advertising growth between July and September, suggesting advertisers became increasingly cautious as summer gave way to fall.


One possible explanation is that this year's World Cup spending may not have been entirely incremental. Wright says Guideline is seeing preliminary indications that some marketers may have funded their World Cup campaigns from existing annual advertising budgets rather than setting aside additional money for the event.


If so, the heavy spending earlier in the year may have left less money available for other advertising campaigns during the second half. Wright however emphasizes that this is a theory suggested by spending patterns, not something Guideline has confirmed directly with advertisers.


The challenges aren't confined to the U.S., either. Wright says Guideline has recently recorded declining advertising spending in the UK, slowing growth in Canada, and essentially flat results in Australia.


Looking ahead, Guideline’s findings suggest the advertising market may need more time to regain momentum. Although political advertising associated with the midterm elections will provide a boost during the fourth quarter, Wright warns election spending could also temporarily disguise the underlying weakness. That could make it difficult to get a clear picture of the advertising market until late in the fourth quarter or early 2027.


"Q4 is going to help us determine whether or not our initial thoughts on the slowing ad market is part of what's at play," Wright says.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page