top of page

Cumulus Seeks More Time To Fight Nielsen In Supreme Court.

4 hours ago
3 min read

Cumulus Media is asking the Supreme Court for another month to fight Nielsen’s appeal in their ongoing radio ratings antitrust battle. But Nielsen isn't willing to wait that long. The ratings company has agreed to give Cumulus one additional week to prepare its response, while opposing the broadcaster’s request for a 30-day extension.


Cumulus has asked the justices to move its deadline from Dec. 7 to Jan. 6, 2027. Cumulus says in a filing that the additional time is needed because the broadcaster’s legal team faces several competing deadlines, including a Nov. 24 oral argument before the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in a related Nielsen case. The filing also cites other pending litigation, scheduled depositions, as well as the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays.


Nielsen has agreed to a Dec. 14 deadline but opposes any further delay. It says that would allow the Supreme Court to decide whether to hear the case in time for arguments during its current term. “A longer extension would, as a practical matter, foreclose that possibility," the company’s response says.


Nielsen argues that Cumulus has already had ample opportunity to prepare its opposition. It also warns that the appeals court ruling could be cited in other antitrust cases while its Supreme Court challenge remains unresolved.


The Supreme Court has not yet ruled on the extension request, leaving the Dec. 7 deadline in place for now.


The disagreement comes after the Supreme Court took the step of requesting a response from Cumulus, which had previously waived its right to oppose Nielsen’s petition unless the justices specifically asked for its arguments. That request has kept Nielsen’s hopes for Supreme Court review alive. It has also set the stage for another round of legal arguments over the company's national and local radio ratings sales policy.


The justices haven’t agreed to hear the case. They are seeking input from Cumulus to help decide whether to review a federal appeals court ruling that upheld an injunction blocking Nielsen from requiring broadcasters to purchase local ratings as a condition of obtaining complete national ratings.


Two Track Legal Fight


The broader dispute dates to October 2025, when Cumulus sued Nielsen over a policy tying access to its Nationwide radio ratings service to purchases of local ratings. Cumulus wanted to continue using Nielsen’s national ratings for its Westwood One network business while purchasing local audience measurement from rival Eastlan in certain markets.


District Judge Jeannette Vargas issued a preliminary injunction last year blocking Nielsen from conditioning Nationwide access on local ratings purchases. The order also prohibited Nielsen from charging commercially unreasonable rates for Nationwide ratings sold separately. The Second Circuit upheld that injunction in July, rejecting Nielsen’s argument that its discounted package of national and local ratings amounted to lawful bundled pricing rather than an anticompetitive tying arrangement.


Nielsen has asked the Supreme Court to overturn that decision, arguing that the appeals court improperly treated ordinary bundled discounts as potentially unlawful without sufficient evidence that its pricing excluded competitors. The company contends the ruling could have implications well beyond radio, potentially exposing businesses in other industries to antitrust challenges over discounted product packages.


Meanwhile, the separate Second Circuit proceedings continue over enforcement of the original injunction. Judge Vargas previously rejected Nielsen’s proposed standalone Nationwide pricing as commercially unreasonable and threatened daily penalties of $50,000 unless the company submitted a revised offer. The appeals court stayed that enforcement order while Nielsen’s challenge proceeds.


For now, the original injunction remains in effect, and the Supreme Court must decide how much time Cumulus will receive to make its case against Nielsen’s petition before the justices determine whether to take up the dispute.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page